Police Blotter

police blotter logo

If you have information about any of the crimes listed below, please contact the Eagar Police Department at 928-333-4127 #4. 

October, November, December 2021

Between September 16th and December 15th, the Eagar Police Department handled 503 calls for service. Of these calls there were 98 animal control calls, 84 agency assists, 259 civil matters, 43 criminal investigations, 7 municipal code issue and 12 collisions.

On September 20, Geneva Ruth Hollingshead, age 22 of Eagar was arrested and charged with Domestic Violence Assault, Criminal Damage and Disorderly Conduct. She was booked into the Apache County Jail.

On September 25, Nicole Traphagan, age 32 of Eagar was arrested and charged with Domestic Violence Assault and 2 counts of Disorderly Conduct. She was booked into the Apache County Jail.

On September 26, Officers took a Theft report from N. Main Street in Eagar. Persons unknown stole a display of Vapes. This case is under investigation.

On October 1, Officers took a Burglary report on S. Butler Street. A drill was taken. This case is under investigation.

On November 3, a 16-year-old male of Eagar was charged with Domestic Violence Assault. He was referred to Apache County Juvenile Probation.

On November 8, Ivan Lee James, age 41 of Eagar was arrested and charged with Dangerous Drug Possession and 6 counts of Drug Paraphernalia Possession. He was booked into the Apache County Jail.

On November 23, Officers responded to a Non-injury Collision on N. Main Street. Shaun Michael Beatty, age 34 of Colorado was charged with Failure to Stop at an Accident, Failure to Provide Information at Accident and Driving on a Suspended License. He was cited and released.

On November 26, Officers took a Criminal Damage report on S. Amity Lane. Much damage was done to the interior drywall of a home. This case is under investigation.

On November 27, John Richard Carlson, age 37 of Springerville was arrested and charged with Aggravated DUI, Criminal Damage, Disorderly Conduct and 7 counts of Misuse of 911. He was booked into Apache County Jail.

On December 7, Justin Allen DeLawrence, age 27 of Eagar was arrested and charged with Domestic Violence Aggravated Assault, Domestic Violence Assault and Disorderly Conduct. He was booked into the Apache County Jail.

On December 15, Lucy Elizabeth Jacobs, age 52 of Eagar was arrested and charged with 3rd Degree Burglary and Interfering with Judicial Proceedings. She was booked into Apache County Jail.

July, August, September 2021

Between June 16th and September 15th, the Eagar Police Department handled 584 calls for service. Of these calls there were 152 animal control calls, 112 agency assists, 267 civil matters, 44 criminal investigations, one municipal code issue and eight collisions.

On June 20, Justin Allen DeLawrence, age 27 of Eagar was arrested and charged with Aggravated Assault, Endangerment, 6 counts of Threaten and Intimidate and 6 counts of Disorderly Conduct. He was booked into the Apache County Jail.

On July 7, John Jason Baca, age 51 of Springerville was arrested and charged with Assault, Threaten and Intimidate and Disorderly Conduct. He was booked into the Apache County Jail.

On July 17, Amanda Jane Gibson, age 29 of Eagar was arrested on a Warrant for Failure to Appear. She was booked into the Apache County Jail.

On July 23, Officers took a Theft report on W. Central Avenue. Bicycle rims and tires were taken. This case is under investigation.

On July 30, Brian Hurd Nelson, age 66 of Springerville was arrested on 2 Warrants for Probation Violation and Failure to Pay. He was booked into the Apache County Jail.

On August 1, Tony Ruiz, age 42 of Eagar was arrested and charged with Resisting Arrest, Criminal Damage, Disorderly Conduct, Dangerous Drug Possession and Drug Paraphernalia Possession. He was booked into the Apache County Jail.

On August 4, Officers responded to a Non-injury Collision on S. Harless Street and W. 4th Avenue. Rosario Hinojos, age 49 of Eagar was charged with a Stop Sign Violation. She was cited and released.

On August 9, Derrick Tsinajinie, age 30 of Eagar was charged with Obstructing a Public Thoroughfare and Disorderly Conduct. He was cited and released.

On August 15, a 16-year-old male of Lakeside was arrested and charged with Resisting Arrest, Failure to Comply with an Officer, Dangerous Drug Possession and Drug Paraphernalia Possession. He was also arrested on 3 Bench Warrants. He was booked into Apache County Juvenile Detention.

On August 28, Officers took a Criminal Damage report on W. School Bus Road. A vehicle was driven into a yard, damaging 2 fences. This report is under investigation.

On August 28, Derrick Tsinajinie, age 30 of Eagar was arrested and charged with Disorderly Conduct, Threaten and Intimidate and Public Nuisance. He was booked into Apache County Jail.

On August 29, Officers took a Burglary report from S. Harless Street. Drywall tools and miscellaneous other household items had been taken. This case is under investigation.

On August 30, Christian Lee Nasse, age 67 of Springerville was arrested and charged with 1st Degree Criminal Trespass and on a Warrant for Failure to Appear. He was booked into the Apache County Jail.

On September 9, a 13-year-old male of Eagar was charged with Drug Paraphernalia Possession. He was referred to Apache County Juvenile Detention.

On September 9, Officers responded to a Private Property Collision off of N. Main Street. Jose Ulices Torres-Gomez, age 22 of Springerville was charged with Leaving the Scene of an Accident. He was cited and released.

April, May, June 2021

Between March 16th and June 15th, the Eagar Police Department handled 530 calls for service. Of these calls there were 109 animal control calls, 109 agency assists, 271 civil matters, 36 criminal investigations, one municipal code issue and four accidents.

On April 21, John Jason Baca, age 51 of Springerville was arrested and charged with 2 counts of Driving Under the Influence and Spirituous Liquor in the Vehicle. He was booked into the Apache County Jail.

On May 4, Vern Turley Sanders, age 51 of Colorado was arrested and charged with Aggravated Assault and Assault. He was booked into the Apache County Jail.

On May 5, Adam Lee Garner, age 26 of Eagar was arrested and charged with Domestic Violence Assault and Domestic Violence Disorderly Conduct. He was booked into the Apache County Jail.

On May 5, Jasmine Christine Whalen, age 31 of Eagar was charged with Domestic Violence Assault and Domestic Violence Disorderly Conduct. She was cited and released.

On May 5, Abram Gerhart Apodaca, age 42 of Eagar was arrested and charged with 2 counts of Domestic Violence Aggravated Assault, Domestic Violence Assault and Domestic Violence Disorderly Conduct. He was booked into the Apache County Jail.

On May 22, Wendy Rachelle Deglane, age 45 of Eagar was arrested and charged with Drug Paraphernalia. She was also arrested on a Warrant for Probation Violation. She was booked into the Apache County Jail.

On June 1, a 15-year-old male of Eagar was arrested and charged with Endangerment, Criminal Nuisance and Domestic Violence Disorderly Conduct. He was booked into Apache County Juvenile Detention.